Johnnie Moore

Learning is not a parcel

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

I’m about to embark on a three-week road trip working with teams of faciliators to share experiences and develop skills. I now hesitate to call it training especially after reading Harold Jarche’s post – Training Evaluation: a mug’s game. Harold links to this spendidly fierce post by Dan Pontefract a pushback to something called the Kirkpatrick Four Levels™ Evaluation Model.

Anything to do with learning that bears a ™ tends to put me in a critical frame of mind for starters. I find it hard to associate the joy of learning with intellectual property chastity belts. And to be honest I find the presence of ™ correlates fairly positively with banality.

Echoing Dan, I feel rather miserable reading statements like this:

any successful initiative starts with a clear definition of the desired outcomes.

It’s management speak and it’s a wild overclaim for a world of complexity and the unexpected.

Both Dan and Harold argue for a far more social way of understanding how learning happens in organisations.

I can understand why management feels pressure to prove some return on investment, but this is a game with unintended consequences. The pressure is on participants to establish they have been “good” learners by affecting to have taken delivery of profound “outcomes” whether they have or haven’t. It puts learners in a childlike position vis-a-vis the training which results in either good boy (thank you, mummy, for that valuable lesson) or bad boy (delete your own expletive) behaviour in response. We end up in the same world as that I talk about in this post on commitment ceremonies.

Learning is not a FedEx package that you sign for at the door. Learning happens on its own schedule. We often realise the significance of events long after their original impact, and may actually continue to revise what we think the lesson is as our lives unfold.

I can see that for some training you might well want to set practical tests and evaluations. But for soft skills, I would put much more emphasis on supporting peer-to-peer sharing and support. Reducing things to models may comfort management that it’s doing something but easily gets in the way of people’s intrinsic desire to learn and to socialise.

Share Post

More Posts


There’s more potential in each moment than we realise

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations


Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

Organic chat

I had a great lunch yesterday with Tom Guarriello and his wife Karen, at my local organic pub. This is the third time I’ve met Tom and the first where

Johnnie Moore

On a lighter note

From Letterman:Top Ten Messages Left on Cat Stevens’ Answering Machine Some of this didn’t translate so well over the Atlantic but I liked 7. “It’s Johnnie Cochran. Without a trial

Johnnie Moore

Propositions about change

Jack Martin Leith seems to have spent a lot of time rearranging his website, deleting stuff then deciding to reinstate it. I know the feeling! I think the results are

Johnnie Moore

The perils of abstraction

Charles Scalfini gives a concise explanation of a way experts often make bad teachers.  As their experience in a subject grows, they are able to form more and more useful abstractions.