Johnnie Moore

Self-organisation is not the opposite of command-and-control

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

Chris Rodgers argues that we confuse self-organisation with empowerment.

Too often, consultants and writers who claim to be speaking from a complexity perspective talk of self-organization as a design parameter. On that basis, they advise managers that they should create structures and systems that will “allow greater opportunity for self-organization to occur”. But, self-organization is not a matter of management choice. It is a given. It occurs just as much in a so-called “command and control” regime as it does in one designed to facilitate widespread self-management.

I think this is a useful perspective. I’ve written before that every process has a shadow, so that whatever ideas we have about how a system works, there will always be some other, less obviously compliant, way in which participants operate. If we get too attached to labelling a system as command-and-control, we risk not seeing the informal networks that operate alongside it and are, probably, symbiotic.

I often have the experience of first seeing a situation as stuck before then discovering there is some other way of responding to it that creates change. Someone will take a rigid stance, people will tell you that this person will never change. And then you may discover something surprising.

Likewise, all too many idealised prescriptions for groovy self-management usually mask some unconscious demand for compliance and control.

Share Post

More Posts

Fluke

There’s more potential in each moment than we realise

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations

Aliveness

Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

London facilitation workshops

I’m going to run a couple of open workshops in November. They’re in London on November 6th and 7th. They’re for anyone who wants to get more out of meetings.

Johnnie Moore

Skype Experience

I’m becoming more and more enthusiastic about Skype (the peer-to-peer voice conversation over the net thingy). Stuart Henshall blogs a lot about it and I agree with him: this is

Johnnie Moore

Auntie gets seriously wired

So I was visiting the BBC yesterday as you do. There was a bit of hoopla going on in reception where a man in a T shirt periodically called out

Johnnie Moore

Negative feeling, positive thinking?

John Tropea turned up this brief report of this research by Annefloor Klep. The gist is summaried in US News thus: Work teams who openly express their negative feelings share