The perils of abstraction

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

Charles Scalfini gives a concise explanation of a way experts often make bad teachers.  As their experience in a subject grows, they are able to form more and more useful abstractions.

But they then attempt to teach their students these abstractions in ways that bypass the experiences on which they are based. If we add to this the high status ascribed to experts, the problem is increased, as students feel they need to act like they understand, still deprived of the underlying experiences from which we truly learn.

And this leaves out the possibility that expert abstractions can be mistaken – which I explored here.

Many training courses are made attractive by offering high-status abstractions, suggesting things like emotional intelligence can be taught by the transfer of dense, expert content.

But many of the most powerful experiences in training come from experimentation and practice, not explanation. (I’ll be exploring this in my January workshop in Cambridge – details here.)

Hat tip: Tweet from Sunil Malhotra

Share Post

More Posts

Ghost lights..

feeling the power of presence… and what it really means to ‘read the room.’

Singing on the subway

What I learned singing to strangers on the subway, and why emotional connections matters even more in a hi-tech era.

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations

Aliveness

Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

What’s risky?

Tom Guarriello has a useful summary of what sounds an interesting talk by Dan Gilbert. Gilbert the Harvard psychologist who wrote Stumbling On Happiness, turned his attention to risk and

Johnnie Moore

Market research: a waste of talent?

I took part in a market research street interview on Friday. I was ushered into a room over a pub and was sat in front of a Tablet PC. It

Johnnie Moore

Shortcuts

Paul Goodison commented on my post about Fundamental Attribution Error. He asks: Isn’t that the point of (traditional) branding i.e. to provide a shortcut to decision making for consumers of

Johnnie Moore

Scaling and Theory U

I really enjoyed Dave Snowden’s reflections on Theory U. I’ve been meaning to write a comprehensive post but those never get written so here are a few reflections for now.