False equivalence

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

Following the debate on airport scanning I keep seeing versions of a particular kind of argument. It takes this form:

I’d rather be groped/x-rayed than blown up by a terrorist

I just want to point out that this fails to recognise that it pits a certainty against a (remote) possibility. I could argue back that if we want to try equating possibilities we might consider weighing the health risks (on which there isn’t an absolutely clear scientific consensus) of the X rays against the apparently statistically remote risks of terrorism.

Share Post

More Posts

Rambling thoughts on models

I went down to Surrey on Friday for long walk and pub lunch with Neil Perkin. We’d originally planned to run a workshop about agile

Planning as drowning

Antonio Dias offers a fascinating description of what goes wrong when drowning: What separates a swimmer from someone drowning is the way a swimmer acknowledges

Leadership as holding uncertainty

Viv picks out some nice ideas from Phelim McDermott on the subject of leadership. “We love the security of the illusion that someone is in

Concreting Complexity

I’ve been thinking about the urge to scale things lately – see here and here. I understand the concern with being able to effect big

The absurd

In moving house, I radically downsized my collection of books which I can highly recommend. I used to think I’d one day find a reason

Who says fun is dangerous?

I wanted to share this email doing the rounds this morning… AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE After every flight Qantas pilots fill out a form called a gripe

Rewriting history…

Thanks to my Improvisation friend Kelsey Flynn I rambled into a letter cited in Margaret Cho’s Blog (go to Letter #1): Lately it seems like

Yes, and…

A quick ramble on the nature of paradox, inspired by a blog on the value of both fear of the new and curiosity

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations

Aliveness

Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

links for 2010-03-09

Shareable: Can We Design Cities for Happiness? “If we in the Third World measure our success or failure as a society in terms of income we would have to classify

Johnnie Moore

The folly of assumptions

Howard Mann’s joke made me laugh. Two beggars are sitting side by side on a street in Rome. One has a cross in front of him. The other one the

Johnnie Moore

Insert your name here

SpotRunner is an online agency selling prefab adverts for $500. You take your pick from a set of standard clips to stitch together your campaign. This Slate video captures it

Johnnie Moore

Top down guide to bottom up

Sean Howard catches a good example of questionable thinking about participation. The International Associaton for Public Participation has put out a one pager (pdf) with a remarkably top down notion