Twisted about Firestarters?

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

At some point I’ll take issue with Mark Earls to prove that he’s not paying me to shill for his book. But for now I’m really digging his stuff.

His latest post points to Duncan Watts’ fascinating analysis of influencers. The research suggests that we easily overestimate the power of “key influencers”. Mark does a good digest. Read the whole thing for the argument, but here’s Watts’ handy metaphor for seeing his alternative paradigm:

Some forest fires for example, are many times larger than average; yet no-one would claim that the size of a forest fire can be in any way attributed to the exceptional properties of the spark that ignited it, or the size of the tree that was the first to burn. Major forest fires require a conspiracy of wind, temperature, low humidity, and combustible fuel that extends over large tracts of land. Just as for large cascades in social influence networks, when the right global combination of conditions exists, any spark will do; and when it does not, none will suffice.

As a former planner, like Mark, I’m all too aware of our talent for post-hoc rationalisation and therefore our ability to come up with plausible but actually quite mistaken stories about how stuff happens. This gives rise to what I’d call the cult of leadership, a tendency to exaggerate the role of charismatic figures in making stuff happen. It’s also why I generally avoid the management porn in airport bookshops.

What this opens up for me is the possibility that those we identify as the firestarters are themselves the effect of a series of more complex causes. We might be confusing cause and effect; they may be bellweathers of trends but not the people we need to influence to make things happen.

And apart from anything else, it might be another reason to take Hugh’s advice and not to get all gnarled up about the influence of A listers.

(There may be a pun about the fires and the futility of cool-hunting but I’ll spare you that.)

Share Post

More Posts

Ghost lights..

feeling the power of presence… and what it really means to ‘read the room.’

Singing on the subway

What I learned singing to strangers on the subway, and why emotional connections matters even more in a hi-tech era.

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations

Aliveness

Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

Hooked on control

Chris Rodgers challenges the everyday complacency with which managers claim to measure results and assess the value of interventions Recognizing this disconnection between mainstream thinking and the messy, complex social

Johnnie Moore

Down Under

I’m off to New Zealand tomorrow night for a holiday. I’ll be 24 hours in the air with a short stop enroute so I hope Singapore Airlines will have some

Johnnie Moore

Ours or theirs?

Like Hugh I like Tony Goodson’s questions: Cluetrain feels like ours. LoveMarks feels like theirs. Why are the battle lines being drawn for Cluetrain v LoveMarks? Isn’t LoveMarks trying to

Johnnie Moore

Blog Pulse

Lots of folks are talking about Blog Pulse Profiles. They weren’t working yesterday but they are this morning. Very clever… and yet another performance measure to distract myself with!