Johnnie Moore

More on what is marketing…

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

Jennifer Rice continues our rolling dialogue about what marketing’s job is. I appreciate Jen for keeping a good thoughtful exploration going. David Foster at PhotonCourier has commented

“I think it’s a stretch to say that “marketing might think of its task as resolving the conflicting needs and interests of stakeholders..” That’s the responsibility of the chairman and the CEO (or in a multidivisional company the division general manager). Attempts by marketing people to claim such a broad scope would disperse efforts and by perceived by many as a territorial grab.”

Very interesting. First, let me say that I don’t claim the rights to say what marketing means, and different people quite fairly use it to describe different things. And yes, I think my suggested definition would be a stretch and is more ambitious in its scope.

David’s comment focuses on the politics, and other people’s anxieties. I hope that marketing does its job tactfully and openly so that it doesn’t create undue fear; but getting some organisations to act with integrity means scaring some people. I’m not arguing for a “land grab” by marketing; but I’m asking for it take responsibility for the promises it makes to customers by making sure that the company delivers sustainably, in a way that works for everyone.

I agree with David that ulitmately this IS the CEO’s job, in which case, the CEO is the top marketing guy. That’s fine with me. Hey, at a stroke we no longer need to listen to those industry hand-wringers who say it’s terrible that marketing doesn’t get enough representation on the board; at a stroke every organisation is headed by a marketing guy. Less facetiously, I think that any function in a business has to get better and better at cooperating with its neighbours, and to do your job really well, you need to be collaborating and overlapping well with other functions.

Jennifer goes on to give an example of a Health education agency whose stakeholders don’t have conflicting needs. I think maybe we’re using different interpretations of the idea of conflicting needs, but I think Doctors and Patients often have conflicting needs – at least in the Health Service over here. Doctors are overworked and need to get through appointments quickly, patients want personal attention and to be listened to. A doctor’s needs for information about eg drugs will be different from those of most patients. I assume this agency has funding needs, so it has to reconcile its target groups thirst for knowledge with the capacity of fund raisers to pay for it all. But I may be mssing the point here… hope Jennifer will forgive me!

Jennifer considers focussing marketing on communicating and that’s an interesting variation, one that I guess makes marketing’s job a bit simpler. Mind you, once you start getting really clear communication between groups, I think you are getting into resolving conflicts. My concern is that marketing people who see it as their job only to “communicate” might interpret this as an excuse to pass on half-truths and say, hey, don’t shoot the messenger. And as Jen says, there’s stuff like pricing to think about too.

Reflecting on this, I want to emphasise the need to recognise and deal with stakeholder conflict skilfully, rather than sweep it under the carpet and spin too many plates. My beef with so much marketing is its tendency to spin wild fantasies by simply avoiding internal conflicts and indulging in wishful thining.

I don’t really mind the label we give to that conflict resolution process providing it’s done; my disillusionment with a lot of marketing is that it really fails to deal with conflicts and often no-one else steps up to the mark.

Or am I getting all too theoretical and pedantic? Maybe. In which case, let’s end on Tom Asacker’s comment:

If the circus is coming to town and you paint a sign saying, “Circus is coming to Fairgrounds Sunday,” that’s Advertising. If you put the sign on the back of an elephant and walk him through town, that’s a Promotion. If the elephant walks through the Mayor’s flower bed, that’s Publicity. If you can get the Mayor to laugh about it, that’s Public Relations. And, if you planned and coordinated the whole thing (including naming, pricing, events, location, concessions, souvenirs, spin-off products, licensing, etc.) that’s Marketing!

Share Post

More Posts

Conversational leadership

David Gurteen tweeted this interesting article (pdf): Conversational Leadership: Thinking together for a change It makes a lot of sense to me pushing for a

Scaling or evolving?

This post really interests me: Innovation for Development: Scaling Up or Evolving? As they complete some pilot experiments in development work the authors recognise that


I’ve just given a presentation on Beyond Branding in Jersey. It was fun to take ideas that have been percolating for months and give them

Badgers and the joy of complexity

Great article in today’s Independent. The government decided to take action to stop the spread of TB among cattle. They found that badgers were to


I’ll be taking part in the Chautauqua online discussion of Beyond Branding, from 15th to 29th February. Fellow authors Denzil Meyers, Chris Macrae, Julie Anixter

Microsoft’s embarassing metadata

Found via Richard Gayle is Strike that Out Sam. This is a cheeky exploitation of the fact that Microsoft Word documents retain the fingerprints of

Iranian Blog

On a tip from David Weinberger I’ve been reading the blog written by the Vice President of Iran. I recommend you take a look. It’s

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations


Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

links for 2006-02-12

BuzzMachine » Congratulations, Rocketboom Jeff Jarvis says “Big advertisers and big agencies are chickenshit. They need to grow some balls or else they’ll find new competitors running circles around them”

Johnnie Moore


Tom Guarriello reflects on Seth’s All Marketers are Liars. Even though he’s not read the book I think he’s written the clearest summary I’ve yet seen (and I have read

Johnnie Moore

Your brain on walking

I know we’re in the early days of of neuroscience and we shouldn’t get too excited about MRI scans. But this little image from this article caught my eye. I

Johnnie Moore

Mob justice

Seth writes about what I’d call ratpacking – a group of bloggers getting carried away attacking something or someone. Not fun to be on the receiving end. And I’m curious for details.