Johnnie Moore

The tyranny of the explicit in marketing

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

I’m continuing to have thoughts in response to reading Herd probably because Mark Earls’ position so often reverberates with mine. There’s nothing like having one’s prejudices supported.

Like me Mark enjoys taking potshots at market research. In particular, the effort to read the minds of individuals in search of the magic insight that will become a lever to engage with the market. I’ve done my share of focus groups where the client sits behind the one-way mirror getting in a twist when the moderator “isn’t getting emotional insights” from the group. It’s as if we can generate genuine insights hygienically, via an intermediary and without the sordid business of emotionally connecting with people. I wonder if we can really get much insight into our fellow man without taking the risk of opening ourselves to him, rather than prodding him like a lab rat. And as Mark says in a comment on his blog, when was the last time you sat in a research meeting and the debrief went essentially: “not really sure what’s happening or why. It’s much more complicated than we thought and indeed than our methodologies can really handle….”?

Related to this, you may be familiar with following notion of how we learn stuff, which I lifted from this article: Smooth your Learning Journey with the Learning Matrix I’m sure this a very useful model, the idea being that we start bottom right and work our way anti-clockwise to bottom left.

But it seems to me a lot of our learning skips the conscious stages altogether, and just skips from box 1 to 4. Vast amounts of what we learn as children and adults is just unconscious copying of what others are doing around us (hence the Herd title of Mark’s book). I contend that most market research values only the stuff that routes via boxes 2 and 3, with a preference for what can be turned into long and clever papers for MRS conferences. The effort to drill down to insights may actually get in the way of really connecting with the audience formerly known as consumers. Of course, as smart beings we can easily conjure up all manner of rationalisations for our behaviour to entertain market reserachers with, but it may not approximate to what’s really going on.

—–

Share Post

More Posts

Focus group flaws

Tony‘s been writing of his first time experiences of focus groups – two in one week. He comments: I attended my first ever advertising focus

Cheap and simple research

I used to do a lot more market research for people. These days I’m doing it less often. I think it’s because I’ve become disillusioned

Blogging at tipping point?

Jennifer Rice first pointed to these stats on blogging a few days ago. Jennifer and I were chatting about them on the phone yesterday, and

Opining for Money

Last night I was paid to take part in a panel of experts (who me?) to give feedback to a financial brand about the trends

The flaws of focus groups

A good article from the Market Research industry trade mag highlights some of the pitfalls of focus groups – how sometimes they reduce the sense of connection with the customer.

The tyranny of the explicit

I think that business suffers from the tyranny of the explicit. Its desire for measurability and proof makes it focus on the explicit element of

We’re all talk radio hosts now…

Jonah Lehrer suggests thinking can often serve to confuse us. He reports research where students had to rate different jams. They managed to come out

Tyranny of the Explicit

Following up on yesterday’s post, a second of our tyranny coatpegs it the Tyranny of the Explicit. Viv talks about it here and it’s something

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations

Aliveness

Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

Opening and closing

Chris Corrigan reports on the Dalai Lama talking about opening and closing.

Johnnie Moore

Diversity and problem-solving

Piers Young reports on research that shows diversity is a key to effective group problem-solving. But he says, our tendency to mix with kindred spirits may be in the way.

Johnnie Moore

DIY corporate press release

Christoper Carfi offers an all purpose corporate press release. [Company name], a [noted | leading | large] provider of [insert industry name here] solutions is [happy | pleased | thrilled]