Johnnie Moore

Vicars and Charts Party?

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

Typically eloquent piece by Simon Caulkin in yesterday’s Observer: The devil is in the details:

How would you appraise a vicar’s performance? By the number, length and quality of sermons? Attendance at church? Out of wedlock births? Ratio of marriages to divorce? Doctrinal purity?

This intriguing question was raised by proposals put forward last week by the Church of England’s General Synod to make incompetent vicars easier to sack, and to subject them to the kind of performance measures that apply to other workers.

Don’t laugh:… In one study, a Norwegian hospital chaplain had performance measures that counted not only bedside visits, but also the number of last rites he performed. In fact, the church’s measurement problem illustrates with blinding clarity the tensions inherent in all performance management.

Caulkin does a great job articulating the paradox of performance measurement. If you are in too much rush to read the whole thing, here’s his key point:

If performance management is both inevitable and impossible, what’s to be done? The answer is to disconnect measurement from control – to reconceptualise it, as professor Andy Neely of the Advanced Institute for Management Research has put it, as a system of learning rather than control.

Yes… mind you, that’s how schoolteachers tried to “sell” me on exams; they had a hard time convincing me of their sincerity!

Share Post

More Posts


There’s more potential in each moment than we realise

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations


Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore


I’ve been doing a lot of thinking – and worrying – about collaboration. I think the ability to collaborate effectively is becoming ever more essential – yet it’s also often

Johnnie Moore

Python’s other other operation

As regular readers know I am a massive Monty Python fan. And having caught up with this (via Geoff Jones), now even more so! —–

Johnnie Moore

links for 2011-07-13

David Hepworth's Blog: The secret of pitching is making them say no Lovely bit of contrary thinking Swiss party makes dislike of PowerPoint a political issue – legislation government, Office