Johnnie Moore

Bzz controversy

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

There’s been a storm of comments about BzzAgent’s deal to promote Creative Commons. Peter Caputa has written something that just about captures my own view: essentially that criticism of BzzAgent is often overdone and a bit self-righteous. And that Dave Balter went a bit OTT in response (credit to him for subsequently apologising).

I’ve been self-righteous myself from time-to-time, it can be very satisfying in the short run to be so damn smart and so damn right. I know the pleasure of nailing up a forensic list of the 12 fatal flaws in other side’s position. This is the joy of advocacy over enquiry. But in the end, I find respectful dialogue is more sustainable. (Learning instead of problem-solving).

Peter also picks up this great insight from Kevin at Corante’s Many to Many:

I think this is because BzzAgents crosses the line between the two moral syndromes that Jane Jacobs identifies in Systems of Survival – the Guardian syndrome, which is based on loyalty and social groups, and the Commercial one, which is based on honest dealing and collaboration with strangers.

Share Post

More Posts

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations

Aliveness

Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

Surowiecki on “fatal flaws”

Rob May spots a nice article by James Surowicki: The Fatal-Flaw Myth. Snippet: People are generally bad at accepting the importance of context and chance. We fall prey to what

Johnnie Moore

Innovation or real needs?

Tim Kastelle has good post The Worst Innovation Quote Ever. That’s the one about inventing a better mousetrap and the world beating a path to your door. Apparently there are

Johnnie Moore

On the court

Evelyn is channeling Lisa Haneberg. Actually she isn’t, she’s just passing on an email. But it’s an amusing thought. Anway, here’s Lisa’s little nugget. There are 2 types of conversations

Johnnie Moore

Storytelling

Shawn Callahan has a great post on The Uncanny Valley of Business Storytelling. The uncanny valley describes what happens as robots become more like humans. As long as they’re clearly