Johnnie Moore

Marketing, the tragedy of the commons and cold turkey

After a panel session on Direct Marketing I wonder if we should stop looking for miracle cures for ailing brands, and instead encourage them to go cold turkey, prolong their confusion, and keep asking searching questions - to find a real sense of purpose to outlast the easy gimmickry of the admen.
Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

Alongside fellow blogger, Chris Lawer, and several industry luminaries I took part in a panel session at the Direct Marketing Show yesterday. The theme was the Nuisance Factor – the increasingly negative image Direct Marketing has among an irritated public.

It was a good debate and most people acknowledged the problem for DM: that’s it’s getting harder and harder to get results from a sceptical public, and the industry’s activities put its practitioners even lower in the public perception than estate agents.

What I see is a sort of tragedy of the commons. Each attempt by marketing to break through the noise sufficiently to engage customer attention just adds to the level of that noise, increasing the irritation and reducing future effectiveness. I might add that the crass nature of many mailshots hardly helps (see this article I penned a few months back: Taking the Gloves Off)

A common response – one we saw in the session – is for marketers to throw their hands in the air and say “but how else can we sell our service?”. The trouble is, for as long as marginal economics encourage them to keep churning out direct mail, they’ll never really ask the question with genuine interest in an answer – as opposed to just asking it rhetorically.

Anyone for Cold Turkey?

I guess that many alcoholics would say “Yes, I know booze is bad for me, but I won’t give it up until I have a substitute!”. There is a (perfectly human and understandable) fear of stepping into the unknown. The temptation is to try to offer DM-aholics the examples of brands that succeed without clumsy push-branding. (And these tend to be the usual suspects… Pret a Manger in the UK, Southwest Airlines, Patagonia blah blah blah).

But I wonder if that is too glib. After all, one of the most interesting characteristics of these brands is that they have been extensively documented and rarely replicated. I think perhaps that failing organisations may have to do the cold turkey, brave the unknown, and ask themselves some searching questions about the value they offer before they can escape the collective dive to the bottom of the barrel.

Yesterday, Chris made the excellent suggestion that one way to differentiate would be for a firm to make a public announcement that it would forswear all advertising and direct marketing and put the budget instead into improving the customer experience. A quick show of hands showed most of the audience was not up for such a strategy. I said that for the few who did put their hands up, this was excellent evidence that they were right – and most businesses would be too frightened to try it.

I think the problem is that too many businesses are selling products without conviction and passion; they stick to the safety of the known. Example: nearly all banks in Britain blather on about targeting the mass affluent, and about customer service. Few, if any, have anything very different to say about their motivation for saying so, or demonstrate any genuine passion for their work. (Kudos to The Cooperative Bank as a notable exception)

I think most brands in some kind of crisis daren’t prolong their confusion. They won’t take the time to really engage in searching conversations with their stakeholders about their purpose. Instead, often under pressure from the teenage scribblers, they reach out for an noisy promotional solution from the admen, making grand promises to the public whilst their staff look on, bemused or downright cynical. I fear this has been, and will continue to be, the fate of Marks and Spencer and Sainsbury’s here in Britain.

Share Post

More Posts

Waterfalls and chaos

I linked to this paper on wicked problems the other day and Chris Corrigan commented “there’s a lot in that paper eh?”. Which is true.

Passion branding

Passion brands bring people together based on common interests and excitements. I’m particularly interested in ones created from the bottom up, as opposed to driven by producers concerned mainly with profit.

Medinge Moments

Just back from another extraordinary gathering at Medinge where the community that has produced Beyond Branding meets each summer. I was planning to keep this

The volatile chemistry of trust

Interesting research from Stanford suggests that exciting brands get more trusted after making mistakes and putting them right whilst more “sincere” brands start with more trust but lose it more easily. Perhaps the sensible interpretation is that second-guessing customers can be a waste of time!

What brand are you?

Thanks to Matt Tucker at Smith Associates for telling me about What Brand Are You. It strikes me that lots of companies waste money on

New Abbey

So the Abbey National is rebranding itself this morning. As I write this entry, they are revealing their new look, their shortened name (just “Abbey”)

Just Undo It?

The AntiBrand: blackSpot sneakers, a project by Adbusters attacks Nike directly. In doing so they take on what has become one of the great icons

Putting humanity into branding

We live in a world of too much marketing and too much branding. People’s faith in advertising has fallen to new lows as we simply

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations


Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

Dr Rant

Chris Locke has Rageboy and I have Dr Rant. Dr Rant is a subpersonality of mine that pops out, often without warning, when I feel the need to vent steam.

Johnnie Moore

Our Social World

I’m taking part in Our Social World on Friday September 9th in Cambridge. There’s an interesting collection of speakers and topics including Hugh who argues “marketeers are going to have

Johnnie Moore

Virgin flight

PSFK’s report on the first Virgin America flight from LAX to SFO makes it sound pretty good.

Johnnie Moore

Random Acts of Madness

Seth asks about a Random Act of Madness. I reflect on one of my own and talk about metaphorically poking spiders in jam jars.