Johnnie Moore

Safety and rank

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

Nancy Dixon writes about the conditions that favour good quality conversations in organisations. She uses the term psychological safety to describe the conditions that allow people to take risks in conversations. She distinguishes that safety from cohesiveness (for which it could be mistaken). The latter may feel safe but really sets everyone up for groupthink. The safety Nancy talks about allows challenging things to be said.

The essential precondition for that kind of safety is largely to do with power differences:

In the study teams that reflected effectively and implemented resulting changes had minimal power differences. The leaders of those teams encouraged input and debate. Where power differences between leader and members were high, little learning occurred.

She goes on to explore how those power differences get increased or reduced. It makes a lot of sense to me. In my work I see a lot of theatre created around people who appear to have a lot of power, and it cuts them off from a lot potetially useful feedback.

I also like this point, which could do with being trumpeted loudly in the ears of many consultants and organisational leaders:

A very hopeful implication of Edmondson’s study is that it is possible to create a culture that supports collective sensemaking within a team or unit, even if other parts of the same organization do not have a compatible culture. This means that it is not necessary to wait on top management support in order for change to occur locally. Nor is it necessary for the whole organization to change in order for any one team to make use of effective learning behaviors.

I have seen too many conversations in which people wring hands, or adopt the physiology of Rodin’s Thinker while talking about how to change “the culture of the whole organisation”. Something on a smaller scale has more chance of success and of then spreading.


Share Post

More Posts

Conversational leadership

David Gurteen tweeted this interesting article (pdf): Conversational Leadership: Thinking together for a change It makes a lot of sense to me pushing for a

Scaling or evolving?

This post really interests me: Innovation for Development: Scaling Up or Evolving? As they complete some pilot experiments in development work the authors recognise that


I’ve just given a presentation on Beyond Branding in Jersey. It was fun to take ideas that have been percolating for months and give them

Badgers and the joy of complexity

Great article in today’s Independent. The government decided to take action to stop the spread of TB among cattle. They found that badgers were to

More on what is marketing…

Jennifer Rice continues our rolling dialogue about what marketing’s job is. I appreciate Jen for keeping a good thoughtful exploration going. David Foster at PhotonCourier


I’ll be taking part in the Chautauqua online discussion of Beyond Branding, from 15th to 29th February. Fellow authors Denzil Meyers, Chris Macrae, Julie Anixter

Microsoft’s embarassing metadata

Found via Richard Gayle is Strike that Out Sam. This is a cheeky exploitation of the fact that Microsoft Word documents retain the fingerprints of

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations


Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

links for 2010-09-23

My introduction to systems thinking – a map by Kielhofner | Yes and Space Geoff Brown talks about his original training in occupational therapy and how the "model of human

Johnnie Moore

Just talking is not necessarily that simple

Nancy Dixon has a meaty post up about some of the things that undermine group conversations. I’m often inclined to say “can’t we just talk” when offered a complicated way

Johnnie Moore

links for 2011-05-29

Make Little Bets for Innovation Success « Innovation Leadership Network Tim Kastelle does a useful digest of the book Little Bets (tags: crumbs!)

Johnnie Moore

Occupational adventure ebooks

I’ve not linked to Curt Rosengren for ages. Meanwhile he’s been very busy. He now offers two ebooks, one reasonably priced and the other completely free. Well worth a closer