Johnnie Moore

When not to give people the answer

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

If you want to build a ship, don’t drum up people together to collect wood and don’t assign them tasks and work but rather teach them to long for the endless immensity of the sea – St Exupery

Do you remember those early days of the internet when people claimed, “content is king”? A lot of money was wasted worshipping at that altar. In a network, connectedness is more important than the stuff being pushed. As Roland put it, conversations, then relationships, then transactions. I think that puts transactions in their proper place.

I think that in the world of corporate training, this lesson has still to be learnt. A lot of value gets attributed to content. People, so we’re led to believe, want the course notes and the attractive binder and to be let in on the inevitable seven secrets.

I think this way of thinking betrays a pretty depressing view of the people to be trained. I think it assumes they are lazy and incurious. For almost any topic you want to learn about, the net makes a huge raft of content available and a plethora of ways to access well-curated versions of it. If people really want to learn about a piece of established knowledge, they’ll go find it for themselves.

So why would you offer training at all? Well, I can think of two broad reasons. The first is that you aren’t really after people making exciting discoveries for themselves; instead you just want them to be obedient and compliant. Fair enough, standard procedures have their place in organisational life. When I was a bumbling amateur pilot I preferred other pilots to stick to the rules when I was in the neighbourhood. Where this goes awry is when it’s not done straightforwardly. When the boss wants people to do things without exposing himself to the risk of actually flat out asking for them. So it’s dressed up as training to make it seem more palatable. Thus the subtext of many training briefs is: “can you train these people for me to be more assertive?”

The second reason you might go for training is for stuff where the established, explicit answers don’t seem to work. Because the learning required isn’t just intellectual. For example, one of my favourite topics: dealing with difficult people.  If that would succumb to just following a series of right answers, we’d all buy book like this and do what it says.

That doesn’t work because this is complex stuff and doesn’t yield to a best-practice approach. Handing a difficult conversations is a full-on physical performance and has more in common with riding a bicycle than solving a crossword puzzle. In that case, you need practice and exploration, hopefully with the support of others. That’s the kind of training I’m most interested in.

It needs to be designed on the assumption that people are smart and inquisitive… which means avoiding the standard training props and pretending there are explicit answers. And it means training for a network rather than a hierarchy; the trainer is more of a facilitator and he needs to resist the lure of the teacher trance. Instead, it’s really about embracing more interesting questions…

Share Post

More Posts

Not being an expert

Another reason I like the problem theatre/action storming approach is it’s good example of moving to a peer-to-peer model of working with groups. If I’m

Action Storming

Action storming from Viv McWaters Viv and I have put up this little slideshare about Action Storming (or Problem Theatre as David Simoes-Brown christened it.)

The little book of action storming

Even as Viv‘s and my book on Creative Facilitation is nearing release into the wild I’m thinking about another little project. I’m tentatively calling it

Illusions of strategy

Mark Earls makes a point worth repeating: The thing thing and the people thing. One of the most unhelpful assumptions I come across most when

Small gestures…

Years ago I was at a fascinating workshop exploring the drama triangle. That’s an idea from transactional analysis that sees people playing one of three

The problem with advice

Edith Zimmerman has some wise things to say about advice: After editing an advice column for two years I’ve decided that there is no such

Turning anxiety into action

Antony Mayfield writes about the psychological benefits of running. It is hard to run. To get yourself out the door is hard. To run the

Talk is Action

I’ve blogged before my concerns about the idea that action is superior to talk. I can understand people getting frustrated when conversations seem to loop

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations


Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore


This comment from BuzzMachine… by Jeff Jarvis… Media is getting personal Perhaps it’s as simple as that. Media was institutional. Now it is personal. By personalizing media, I don’t mean

Johnnie Moore

On philosophy, basilisks and branding.

Tom Asacker’s blasts against philsophical blogging about brands, provoking me to contrast the Transactional Game of business with the desire for relationships

Johnnie Moore


David Gurteen makes some interesting connections to my post a few weeks back on willpower and its limits. This is the kind of research that is so important as it

Johnnie Moore


Rob Paterson quotes William Manchester, describing why he jumped hospital ship to rejoin his wartime unit and face near-certain death: And then, in one of those great thundering jolts in