Market research pratfalls

Johnnie Moore

Johnnie Moore

I’m Johnnie Moore, and I help people work better together

Tom Hamilton had me laughing this morning with this comment.

I spent much of yesterday travelling from London to Leeds and back by train and on the return journey I was handed a market research questionnaire for me to fill in to tell GNER what I thought of various aspects of their service. It included the following question:

Please tell us how far you agree with the following statements about GNER catering:

1) GO EAT from GNER provides fresh local food.

Local food? I’m on an intercity train. I’m travelling hundreds of miles at high speed. I have no idea what it would mean to say that the food I’ve bought in the buffet car is local (from Yorkshire? from London? from somewhere in between?); I’m inclined to assume that it isn’t local or that even if it was five minutes ago it isn’t any more; and I don’t care.

He also points to Chris Dillow’s related post containing this coverage from The Times of another case of the perils of market research:

Unveiling the final episode of the current run yesterday, Russell T. Davies, the writer, revealed that pre-transmission market research suggested that the BBC was heading for a £10 million disaster. He said: The research found that no one wanted to watch Doctor Who. Kids said it was a programme for their parents. The parents said it was a dead show. I expected it to die a death after one year. The research paper, based on interviews with viewers, is now gathering dust in a BBC marketing executive’s drawer. It found that viewers thought Doctor Who was a niche series for science fiction geeks, far from the family audience BBC One was seeking. The flop Thunderbirds feature-film revival was raised as a discouraging comparison. But the series has attracted seven million viewers, obliterating ITV1’s Saturday night competition, while remaining a critical success.

Share Post

More Posts

Focus group flaws

Tony‘s been writing of his first time experiences of focus groups – two in one week. He comments: I attended my first ever advertising focus

Cheap and simple research

I used to do a lot more market research for people. These days I’m doing it less often. I think it’s because I’ve become disillusioned

Blogging at tipping point?

Jennifer Rice first pointed to these stats on blogging a few days ago. Jennifer and I were chatting about them on the phone yesterday, and

Opining for Money

Last night I was paid to take part in a panel of experts (who me?) to give feedback to a financial brand about the trends

The flaws of focus groups

A good article from the Market Research industry trade mag highlights some of the pitfalls of focus groups – how sometimes they reduce the sense of connection with the customer.

Survey fatigue

I’ve just completed a survey handed to me at Euston station the other day. It’s one of those standard multiple choice jobbies. Don’t ask me

The tyranny of the explicit in marketing

I’m continuing to have thoughts in response to reading Herd probably because Mark Earls’ position so often reverberates with mine. There’s nothing like having one’s

The “I love data” guy

Oh another nice moment from the IMC conference was running into Bill Tancer. Bill was on a panel I moderated and introduced himself as someone

MRS conference

James and I put in an appearance at the Market Research Society Conference in London yesterday. We gave a short talk about Blogging and listened

More Updates

Emotional debt

Releasing the hidden costs of pent up frustrations

Aliveness

Finding the aliveness below the surface of stuck

Johnnie Moore

The opposite of hype

Adrian Trenholm points to Bessemer Venture Partners Anti Portfolio. Essentially a list of their big mistakes. I agree with Adrian, it’s a good example of marketing that avoids the presentation

Johnnie Moore

Is branding dead?

Hugh Macleod has been saying that Branding is Dead and Doc Searls agrees. Robert Scoble disagrees. Well it all depends on what you mean by branding, and it means different

Johnnie Moore

To focus or not to focus?

Several bloggers are talking about Focus today. And Elevator Pitches. Sometimes focus is good, but there’s a lot to be said for peripheral vision. This entry explores that idea with a lot of references to other folks. And concludes the answer is proably
: Yes, And

Johnnie Moore

Blogging at tipping point?

Jennifer Rice first pointed to these stats on blogging a few days ago. Jennifer and I were chatting about them on the phone yesterday, and Robert Paterson highlights the same